Statute Barred Limitation of an Action: Effects, Causes and Court Proceeding

STATUTE BARRED LIMITATION OF AN ACTION: EFFECTS, CAUSES AND COURT PROCEEDING.

Fajenyo Samuel Ifeoluwa

University Of Jos

INTRODUCTION

THE FORGOTTEN DEBT

Ifeoluwa lent his friend, Peace, the sum of 100,000 naira in 2010. They both agreed that Peace was going to pay back the loan within 3 years. However, Peace never repaid the loan and Ife never pursued legal action.

Twelve years later, in 2022, Ife suddenly remembered the debt and decided to sue Peace for the unpaid loan. Peace lawyer argued that the case was Statute barred, as the limitation period for debt recovery had expired.

WHAT THEN IS STATUTE BARRED?

Statute Barred is used in a legal action that cannot be brought to court because too much time has passed I.e. it refers to a legal action that cannot be initiated due to the expiration of the statutory time limits defined by The Limitation Act of 1963 . This principle serves to protect defendant from stale claims and promote timely resolution of disputes. The defendant can raise the statue barred defense in court.

If the court determines and finds out that an action is indeed statute barred, it will dismiss the case preventing that plaintiff from pursuing the claim despite valid grievances.

EFFECT OF STATUTE BARRED

The primary effect is that the plaintiff losses the right to bring the claim, even if the underlying grievance is valid.

CASUSES OF STATUTE BARRED

Statute barred action arises when a plaintiff fails to initiate legal proceedings within the prescribed time frame, often due to negligence or delay.

COURT RULE ON A STATUTE BARRED CASE

If a defendant raises the defense of Statute Barred, the court will Dismiss the action in favor of the defendant. The court may also order the plaintiff to pay the defendant's legal costs. Before the court will pronounce a case statute barred, the court will consider:

1. The relevant limitation period for the specific action

2. The date when the cause of action arose

3. The date when the plaintiff knew or should have known about the cause of action

LIMITATION OF AN ACTION

Limitation of an action is a law that sets the maximum time in which parties involved in a dispute must institute a legal proceeding following an alleged offense. The time depends on the offense and location.

But there is an exception to limitation of an action:

Though it applies to both civil and criminal cases, more serious offenses such as murder or war crimes often have no statute of limitation. In civil law, in matters relating to consumer debt, the debt becomes time barred debt after the statute of limitation has passed.

BENEFIT OF A STATUTE OF LIMITATION:

A statute of limitation is sometimes controversial due to cases where legal action cannot be brought against an offender because the maximum length of time has elapsed.

Nota Bene: As time goes on, important evidence may be lost, and the memories of the witness can grow foggy. Legal proceeding brought under this circumstance may not be fair to all parties.

PURPOSE OF A STAUTE OF LIMITATION

The purpose of the statute of limitation is to protect would be defendants from unfair legal action, primarily arising from the fact that after significant passage of time.

DOWNSIDE OF STATUTE OF LIMITATION

The obvious significant limitation is the statute of limitation can inadvertently protect wrong doers. For example: If a crime or wrongful act remains undiscovered until after the statute of limitation has expired, the perpetrators may escape legal consequences.

Conclusively, the statute barred, and limitation of an action serves as a mechanism that ensures timely resolution of disputes and prevents stale claim from being brought to court. Ultimately the court ruling in favor of the defendant when a case is declared Statute barred underscores the importance of prompt legal action and the need for plaintiff to be mindful of the time limits that governs their claims.